Best Service, Best Price & 100% Satisfaction Guaranteecall toll free1-855-982-9746

8am – 5:30pm CST, Monday – Friday

Get a Free Quote

About Cooperstown

Cooperstown is the home of baseball, and acts as a beacon for all the great values of the game, including

  • Heritage
  • Integrity
  • Cultural exchange.

As an old-fashioned, family-run company, we share those values.


Pins have been part and parcel of the baseball experience for decades. Exchanging a pin with a fellow player is a symbol of respect and social interaction that generations of young players have found exciting and rewarding. Indeed, many adults still look back fondly on the pins of their youth, and vividly remember the feeling of pride and achievement.

Our mission is to create pins for today’s generation that match the quality of the pins from days gone by, in both craftsmanship and originality of design.


Since 2003, we’ve made thousands of pins for baseball teams all over America. Our personal service means we’re here for you every step of the way, ready to help you turn your ideas into life and create a pin that the whole team can be proud of.

For this reason, you’ll find us very easy to deal with.

  • We keep our promises and always do what we say. You can be sure you’ll have a design that the whole team will be happy with, delivered on time.
  • We’re easy to speak to as we’re always here during office hours Monday to Friday – just pick up the phone.
  • Your calls are answered by us here at the design studio, not an impersonal call center.
  • If you send an email we usually answer within 24 working hours.
  • We do our level best to get artwork and quotes back to you within around 24-72 hours.
  • From the very start, you’ll have direct contact with the graphic artist will design and oversee the making of your pins. We’re happy to answer any questions and we’ll keep you informed at every stage

Cultural exchange

When you exchange pins at a trading event you want your pin to be original and represent the heart and soul of your team.
That’s why every pin we create is designed from scratch by our experienced and talented graphic artists and we never use templates. Whether you have a definite vision in mind, or want some ideas from us, we’ll listen carefully to your requirements and keep on refining the design until you’re completely happy with it.

Quality is vital too, which is why we use the finest quality metals and colors. Pins are inspected during every stage of production so you can be sure they will arrive with you in perfect condition.

Cooperstown quality pins to suit every budget

Although we never compromise on quality of product of service, we also aim to be the best in value too.

Not every team has an unlimited budget for pins. When money is an issue, then talk to us first, as our designers have lots of creative ideas to cut the cost without cutting the quality.

Often it’s simply a matter of choosing a slightly different size, opting for different color method or simplifying the shape. These small changes can lead to big savings without reducing the quality of the pin. Our range is massive, and because we design everything from scratch, you have lots of options.

No-one works harder to create a pin for your team that will make the Cooperstown experience everything they’d ever dreamed of.